Movie Review :: The Deputy
![]() |
| ©2026 Well Go USA |
‘The Deputy’ is a fun crime thriller where the scale is small but the impact is large.
by Jeremy Fogelman
Cast: Duke Nicholson, William H. Macy, Tiffany Haddish, Stephen Dorff, Devon Ross, Julia Fox, Billie Lourd
Rating: ★★
I’ve stayed out of the whole “nepobaby” debate, because my feeling is that it’s hard to get into the industry and people leverage what they can. Instead I focus on whether or not the nepobabies are talented, of which many are and some are not. And sometimes you see a last name and a young, unknown actor and think “Hmm, okay, let’s see about this one.”
The Deputy comes from director Matt Sukkar and writers Carlo Bernard and Victor Gischler, in Matt’s first feature film (after shorts and music videos), adapted from Gischler’s 2010 novel of the same name, starring Duke Nicholson (grandson of Jack) as young rookie deputy Toby Sawyer working in a small town, desperate to find meaning. Toby is a bit of a mess, eager to please but as green as they come, with a baby back home with his supremely toxic girlfriend Doris (fellow nepobaby Billie Lourd) while casually hooking up with local eighteen year old (although I think in the book she’s underage) Molly (mild nepobaby Devon Ross -- although I think this is the last nepo in the bunch).
Local police chief, the grizzled Kreuger (William H. Macy), gives Toby a simple assignment -- merely keep an eye on a dead body, a local tough guy and thug, one of the Jordan brothers. Eventually we do meet the other two, the hulking Derrick (Ben Smith-Petersen) and the hyper-violent Jace (Daniel Diemer) as they try to figure out who killed their brother, but first, the mystery starts -- Toby takes a teensy little break to hook with his teenage sidepiece, and when he gets back the body is gone.
And at this point, he has no idea what happened to it, and the Jordan brothers are out on the warpath because they think Toby had something to do with it. Toby panics but starts his investigation, hoping the chief doesn’t uncover his failures -- he’s at odds with the older officer Billy (Stephen Dorff, plenty scummy as is often his type), but hoping to convince more levelheaded officer Amanda (Tiffany Haddish, a bit against type here in a pleasant surprise). Even Julia Fox shows up in a small role as a cashier clerk, although that just seems more like a little cameo than anything major.
![]() |
| ©2026 Well Go USA |
Ultimately he uncovers a hidden conspiracy about traffickers and stolen funds, with the connections far wider than he initially realized. At the same time, he’s trying to avoid getting killed by the traffickers, hide from the Jordans, clear his name about the dead body, and maybe rescue some innocents along the way. It doesn’t help that his girlfriend is sick of the town (perhaps understandably) and wants to get out of there.
The movie stays brisk, a bit of a slow start, but once the action starts, it’s easy to root for this undertrained but well meaning goofball, someone who’s made plenty of mistakes but is no criminal unlike many around him. It’s a good arc to see his competence improve over the course of the movie, and he has a good rapport with Tiffany Haddish as a fellow officer -- so trying to overcome the “deputy” starting point and becoming the better version of himself.
The story isn’t exactly the most complicated or clever, but I can’t speak to how different it is from the novel. I suspect there’s a lot more details about the backstory of Toby there, because he’s pretty thinly drawn here -- not sure either how much the original author had an impact on this screenplay either, but I found nepobaby Duke Nicholson to be a pretty decent hero here, not great, but easy to root for and appreciate his growth. A pretty decent if not amazing crime flick.
The Deputy has a run time of 1 hour 40 minutes, and is rated R for violence/bloody images, language and some sexual content/nudity.





Comments
Post a Comment